A discussion on the objectivity of history

Or, more plausibly, two people could step outside, one describing the weather as chilly, the other describing it as pleasant. This agreement should, at least prima facie, support an assertion to objectivity as it does for, say, judgments about the temperature outside.

Richards went after the big question too: Can We Know Objective Reality. To call someone cruel is to reprehend him or her. They are the result of judgments not necessarily compelled by the facts but flowing from the mental make-up of the historian.

Particular instances of colors and sounds as they are perceived are prime examples of things that exist only when there are appropriate conscious states. It says a lot that some Northerners know little more of the South than "Gone with the Wind". Second, he notes that no scientific hypothesis is ever confirmed beyond reasonable doubt—some probability of error always remains.

Both approaches boast an attempt at objectivity. While Lorraine DastonRobert Richardsand Peter Galison each explore different episodes in that history, they share a taste for the philosophical questions that hover around the study of science and society.

Objectivity and Bias in the Study of History

They therefore subject decisions to public scrutiny, which means that they must be made in a publicly accessible form. It is a question with deep roots on the Columbia campus, which has been home to a number of the greatest scholars in the field: They thought every single southerner owned a plantation.

But scientific results should certainly not depend on researchers' personal preferences or idiosyncratic experiences. Bernard Williams makes a related point about explanation: Historical knowledge is not purely intuitive because it is derived from a critical examination of source material and is checked by further reference to the source.

An objective fact is inherently beyond history, yet the idea of objectivity arose under specific circumstances. The second step is to realize or postulate that since the same properties that cause perceptions in us also have effects on other things and can exist without causing any perceptions at all, their true nature must be detachable from their perspectival appearance and need not resemble it.

While the experiences vary, there seems to be something that remains constant. It casts the very distinction between epistemic and contextual values into doubt.

Carnap is interested in determining the degree of confirmation of a hypothesis relative to a given set of observations. David HumeNon-cognitivismand Subjectivism The term, "ethical subjectivism", covers two distinct theories in ethics.


One answer to this question has been given by Arthur Fine who argues that we value objectivity in this sense because it promotes trust in science Fine This post-modernist writer views that historical objectivity is oxymoron and the history is more of an entertainment than an arm of academic study.

William James, another ethical subjectivist, held that an end is good to or for a person just in the case it is desired by that person see also ethical egoism.

One last prominent style of usage for terms related to objectivity deals with the nature of support a particular knowledge-claim has. We can know individual things objectively, but not perfectly. At the appropriate midpoint we gain a unique vantage point from which to survey how some individuals and communities come to claim a special relation to the really real and succeed in being believed.

Scientific Objectivity

Viewed this way, scientific knowledge is distinguished precisely by having transcended local conditions. Where do these methods leave the historian of science in relation to the pursuit of the sciences proper?.

Historical Examples. of objectivity. Such a writer is objective, but his objectivity with him is no more than a literary method. Objectivity definition, the state or quality of being objective: He tries to maintain objectivity in his judgment.

See more. Because of the very fundamental nature of the distinction between objectivity and subjectivity, atheists who engage in any sort of philosophical discussion with theists on issues like morality, history, justice, and of course the need to understand these concepts.

Synonym Discussion of objective intention, intent, purpose, design, aim, end, object, objective, goal mean what one intends to accomplish or attain. intention implies little more than what one has in mind to do or bring about.

Read this article to learn about the objectivity and bias in history: Historical knowledge is not purely intuitive because it is derived from a critical examination of source material and is checked by further reference to the source. Historical objectivity is closely related to value-judgment.

Objectivity (philosophy)

Any serious study of the nature of objectivity and objective knowledge should examine the central metaphysical and epistemological positions of history’s leading philosophers, as .

A discussion on the objectivity of history
Rated 4/5 based on 76 review
Can the idea of objectivity have a history?